Tuesday, March 23, 2010

Combining low tech warehouse operation with high tech online retailing

I came across a very good article on WSJ about Ocado, an online grocer in UK using hi-tech warehouse operations to get higher operational accuracies. I remember about 10 yrs back when I was an Industrial Engg. student at GATech, there used to be a company called Webvan (which later on went bust along with many web start ups) that would deliver groceries to your door step within a user defined time window based on an online list that your created. I found the idea neat but was puzzled about how they kept up high service levels and low costs (most of their pricing was comparable to neighborhood Kroger). Turns out the confusion was well founded, Webvan folded within a year (it has been resurrected by Amazon lately). Coming back to the article on Ocado, the entire warehouse is laid out with conveyors of different color coding with totes running through the tracks that go from one order station to another where picking staff can look up the order and drop item into the tote. The sequence in which totes go from one packing station to another is determined by sophisticated algorithms. I have worked before in warehouse with that high level of automation but that was a hi-tech manufacturer. Grocery makes it much more complex where you would need to have different regions for temperature control, dryness etc. That probably explains color coding of conveyors. What is impressive is the volume that flows through the warehouse - 90,000 orders/week covering 65% of British Zip Codes from a single warehouse.

Thursday, February 11, 2010

Apple and Network Effect

I am sure a lot of you must have heard about how Apple's new offering - iPad doesn't support Adobe's Flash application. I came across two different articles on WSJ on two different days that seem to indicate an interesting phenomenon. For analogy sake lets say a hypothetical car maker made a brand new car that wouldn't work on half the roads in the nation. Their reasoning being that soon the standards on quality of roads is going to change anyways and there will be much better roads so why bother to drive on the excluded half. Now how many would buy that car? Well Apple is doing something similar, its expecting that HTML5 standards would eventually become the norm for immersion based website experience and eventually replace Flash as a preferred medium for rendering video content on its site. Probably, Apple calculates that there are enough iPhone users and there will be enough iPad users to make popular websites want to have a special version of their websites for such users. Another motivation one of the articles cites is that with its large base of users that will be unable to view video content on Flash based video sites will be drawn to iTunes thereby generating more value for Apple. Is this what the article refers to as "Microsofting of Apple"? About 2 decades back MS gained advantage through network effect generated by more and more customers buying PCs with Windows install leading to it becoming and industry standard (I know....there is enough anti-MS vibe out there that would cry EVIL but the fact still remains). Wonder if Apple will manage to do the same for iTunes through blocking Flash? Well in the heydays of MS, there wasn't a Google crying "don't be EVIL"

Thursday, February 4, 2010

Technological Innovation and Business Strategy

As we have been discussing more and more in the class about aligning the technology strategy with the business and org strategy, the question becomes more interesting when we are talking about technology companies itself. The business strategy has to match internal and organizational capabilities with the emerging market opportunities in the technological space. When we think about most innovative tech companies, the first name that comes to mind is Apple. With the spate of successful products in the recent past, Apple definitely is paving the way for the next generation of technology based devices. A decade or more back, the same position used to be identified with another technology giant - Microsoft. A company that made PC and Windows ubiquitous. So why dont we see the next wave of innovations coming from them? Wrong org strategy perhaps? I came across a very interesting article on NYTimes written by an ex VP at MS. The ex VP used to run the group that developed the technology that could have been used for an e-reader or tablet PC but got thwarted due to internecine wars within MS. In his own words "Part of the problem is a historic preference to develop (highly profitable) software without undertaking (highly risky) hardware. This made economic sense when the company was founded in 1975, but now makes it far more difficult to create tightly integrated, beautifully designed products like an iPhone or TiVo". Did MS miss the boat on changing market landscape to realign its business strategy and thereby its org structure?

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

iPad

Not sure if you saw the presentation by Jobs on the new Apple product - iPad. I am still trying to wrap my head around why would you buy it if you had a Mac and an iPhone. What is so great about it? The fact that it is thin? well you have the Mac Book Air which is in the same range of thinness. Jobs quotes - "Its so much more intimate than a laptop and so much more capable than a smartphone". I remember last spring as part of the marketing class MBA 8145 we had to do a marketing plan for a new product and company. We created a product called iFridge to be marketed by Apple. The idea was to target the busy mom's market where they could have an interactive task pad with calendar, mail, music, digital post-its etc. And ofcourse it was slammed by a lot of students questioning the value of it in light of a smart phone. That makes me think about what is Apple's real competitive advantage. Is it really to come up with conceptually new products? or is it something else. If you think about it, they did not create the idea of an MP3 player. Infact there were many more mp3 players when they entered the market. They made some critical design innovations around the mp3 player to make it feel cooler and simpler to use. I think they are doing the same thing with the tablet PC. Its not a new idea...there have been players before who have tried their hand at selling them and have essentially been relegated to niche markets. I remember reading in the Gallaugher article about resource based view and what makes a resource a competitive differentiator. I think in case of Apple, its their design culture and brand image that is associated with it that makes it such a potent player. Whether iPad takes off or not, only time will tell but Apple's approach in this case is in lock step with their business strategy.

Friday, January 22, 2010

My first MBA8125 post

I have written blog posts before but they were mostly related to writing on a topic rather than an experience. So this one is definitely new for me. My first thoughts on the idea of our class blogging their experience is one of guarded curiosity. What exactly is this leading to. Maybe no one knows really. But I like the idea of user feedback to what happens in class. Infact thats where all the technologies seem to be leading to. If pretty much everything from restaurants to auto shops to hair dressers can have user ratings and comments online then why not an MBA class? When I registered for this course I kept questioning why do I need to do a course in IT when I have been working in it for more than 5 yrs? But my first impression from the kick-off class was its going to be an interesting journey. There seems to be so many components to the course content. I have never been in this kind of class before. I enjoyed participating in the IT Jeopardy. I definitely look forward to learning something new and interesting from this course.